Showing posts with label book reviews. Show all posts
Showing posts with label book reviews. Show all posts

Tuesday, July 17, 2018

Making Great Conversationalists: Preface and Chapter One - Part One

I'm sorry for dropping off the blogosphere for a week.  My little guy had a bunch of medical appointments while working on erupting his canines.  His left eye has been deviating inward especially when he was tired so he needed a few extra tests to figure out how much deviation there was.  Long story short: he's getting glasses next week along with patching his right eye for one hour every day.  Let me tell you: young todders adore having a dark, sticky patch stuck over their eye!  It's a great excuse to show his newest skill - temper tantrums.   Thankfully, we still had some really awesome toys (read: noisy electronic toys for toddlers) that I had stashed away after Christmas.  Having some "new" toys to play with while having his patch on makes it easier. 

Little Guy has also learned how to pull himself up on furniture and people.  I'm glad he hit that milestone - but he's having to re-learn how depth perception works while standing.  He's a fast little guy, so he's taken a few spectacular falls already.  I'm fighting the urge to make suits of clothing out of bubble wrap for him - or at least a helmet whenever he's out of his crib.

Magically, he took a three-hour nap today - and I used the time to start transcribing the hillarous crazy-land that is "Making Great Conversationalists" by Steven and Teri Maxwell.   I knew that this book was totally worth the $3.00 or so I paid for it from a second-hand book seller when I read the the first two sentences in the book:

This book was conceived after many discussions our family had in the past ten years about the difficulty of having meaningful conversations with others. We realized this was because of a lack of conversation skills on the part of others. (pg. 7)

Man, those two sentences crack me up every time! 

The level of insularity and hubris blows my mind - and the author is completely unaware of either.   Taking the sentences at face value, eight adults spend ten years trying to figure out why talking with people outside of their family-cult is hard and their final conclusion is that the problem lies with the other people.     Additionally, the family think-tank realizes that although they cannot hold a satisfying conversation with outsiders the family does have the skills to write a book to teach outsiders how to hold good conversations....

Remember, the main issue talking with a member of the Maxwell family is that the family has reached an insane level of sheltering where they do not watch TV, movies, or theater, do not read fiction, do not follow professional sports, do not participate in team sports, and don't do any outdoor recreational activities besides hiking as a family.  They do semi-CrossFit-like home exercises, run, drink coffee, bother random service workers about their salvation status and author random books. 

The rest of the preface of the book is the same rah-rah self-help spiel as every preface written in CP/QF land - so I'll spare you the boredom. 

 The first chapter walks the reader through four "typical" conversations followed by four "improved" conversations that are within reach for families who use this book.  Personally, the "typical" conversations often don't teach the lesson the Maxwell authors want the readers to learn.    Let's look at the first scenario involving a mother, her 5-year-old, and a non-threatening stranger.

Have you ever taken a child to the grocery store and had this experience? A pleasant Grandma looks at your five-year-old and tries to engage her in a conversation.

" Hello, sweetie. Those pigtails are just too cute. What's your name?"

Your child looks down at the floor and says nothing while you feel like melting into the floor yourself. However, you cheerfully attempt to prompt your child to answer.

" Tell the nice lady your name, honey."

No response. "Mommy said to tell her your name!"

Still no response so you continue to press. " You need to tell the lady your name!" By this point the grandma is looking decidedly embarrassed and obviously wishing she had not asked the little girl her name. (pgs. 9-10)

At this point, there are two people who are acting appropriately for their age and the situation - and one person who is acting like a crazed martinet.    Five-year-old Cynthia is acting like a standard kindergartener who is nervous about being expected to talk to a stranger.   Cynthia's mom, on the other hand, is throwing a hissy fit at her kid because the kid isn't performing on demand.   The kindly Grandma is probably feeling horrible that she's caused the crazy lady in front of her to lose it; after all, nice grandmotherly-types have had decades of experience with nervous children who are afraid to talk to strangers.

Personally, I was a shy chatterbox.  If I didn't know a person - or was expected to strike up a conversation unexpectedly - I would be frightened and tongue-tied at first.   My parents handled the situation by waiting a short time to see if I would respond and if I didn't would gently answer the question while chatting with the person.  This would buy me some time to "warm up" to the person - at which point I became a torrent of random chatter.

The weirdest bit of the conversation so far is the fact that Cynthia's mother has turned this into an entire power-play battle for control.   She's acting like Cynthia's health or well-being is threatened because Cynthia doesn't want to talk to a random stranger.   It's not.  Hell, it's not even a sign that Cynthia doesn't understand social cues because she's five!

Finally, your daughter mutters under her breath, " Cynthia."

" What was that, my dear? I am sorry. I couldn't understand you," the grandma replies.

So you try again." Speak up louder, and say your name clearly."

Again Cynthia says her name but still not so the lady can understand. You finally step in and tell her Cynthia's name. (pg. 10)

I don't believe for a second that Grandma would have any response to the kid other than "What a nice name!" even if the kid was completely inaudible.   Seriously - don't give the crazy lady another reason to start pressuring her kindergartener. 

Side note: the name Cynthia is one heck of a mouthful for a kindergartener.  Expecting her to say her name clearly might be beyond her speech capacities.  I say this as a fellow person with a tricky first name; most kids pronounce my first name "Melinda" as "Ma-WIN-da" in kindergarten - including me.

This is a typical interaction for an adult with a five-year-old. It's what happens most of the time. How would you feel, though, if this were the way the conversation went instead?

" Hello, sweetie. Those pigtails are just too cute. What's your name?"

Your child looks at the grandma, smiles, and replies, " Thank you. My mommy likes to sometimes make pigtails for me. My name is Cynthia. What's your name?" (pg. 10)

Well, since you asked how I felt, I would be weirded out.   Most kids don't ask random strangers what their names are.  I have no idea how to respond to the fact that Cynthia is wearing pigtails because her mom likes to put Cynthia's hair in pigtails.  Does Cynthia like pigtails?  Does anyone care if she does? 

This whole conversation reminded me of a CP/QF point-of-pride that might be putting their kids at risk.  CP/QF homeschooling parents often wax poetic about how their kids spend all their time in intergenerational settings instead of being surrounded by their peers.   That sounds all well and good - but it also means that their kids are oblivious to the fact that adults don't usually spend time with random kids.    I do water aerobics for exercise and sometimes workout during busy "Open Swim" times.  Generally, people assort by family groups or peer groups.   There's usually groups of boys and girls within a few years of each other playing some game while the parents chat or exercise.    As an adult woman without a kid with me, my interaction with the kids in the pool is limited to occasionally retrieving a toy that has floated into an area that's too deep for the kid to go safely.    The kid gets my attention and asks if I can get the toy on the edge of the deep end.  I say, "Sure!" and return the toy to the kid who says "Thanks!" and we all go about our merry ways.   If I were to join in the kids' game when no other adults are playing -or strike up a conversation with the kid without involving their parent in some way - I would be behaving in a very strange manner would be at least uncomfortable for most kids.   

Well, I'm going to stop there for now.  The next section of stilted dialogue revolves around a teenager at a doctor's office. 

Wednesday, January 3, 2018

Maidens of Virtue: Chapter Seven

The last chapter was a denouncement of the evils of jeans.  Clearly, jeans cause sexual harassment and should be outlawed - or at least worn under shapeless dress.

In this chapter, we learn that Stacy McDonald thinks all teenagers are goths and that goths are terribly unhappy inside.   Oh, she wraps up the chapter by declaring that even Christan women are not visible markers of purity any more - but it's mainly about what Stacy McDonald thinks all teenagers are like.

Oddly enough - I worked with quite a few students who were a lot like the "Modern Mandy" she derides.  I found them to be delightful and easier to be around than the average neurotic CP/QF adherent who has been taught that everything is a sin and that they are corrupting every male simply by being alive.

Mandy spends hours "texting" friends during the day; and, at night, she spends hours on various online social forums. She and her friends post hundreds of photos of themselves, all striking seductive poses for their ever changing profile pics.

Since Mandy's hair usually hangs in her face, it may be difficult to notice that she rarely smiles - smirking doesn't count. But, regardless of her hairstyle, her general look of disrespect, defiance, and boredom is unmistakable and clearly reveals the misery in her heart. (pg. 70)

I am fascinated how parents of home schooled students apply realities of home schooled life to traditionally schooled teens willy-nilly.  Most traditionally schooled teens don't have hours during the day or night available for texting.  Oh, some kids furtively - or not so furtively - send messages during class periods - but that gets in the way of taking notes, doing classwork, or finishing homework from another class.  Sure, some kids use the passing and lunch periods as a frantic time of texting - but they've also got to get to another class and sometimes even talk to other students around them.

Likewise, traditional schools take up time in the evenings with homework and with after-school activities.   If Mandy is not on a college-prep track, she will still have math homework most nights along with occasional writing assignments from her other classes.  If she's on a college prep track, she's probably got several hours of homework to fit around activities like a Writer's Club, sports, music, theater or a job.

I worked with students who had dropped out or been kicked out of traditional high schools.  We were not supposed to assign homework - but kids who had a lot of absences ended up needing to work on missing work after school.  Other students were trying to make up lost credits by completing entire classes in their spare time.  Many kids had children of their own - but even kids without babies had younger siblings or cousins who needed to be watched and tended while their parents were at work.

On a unrelated note, get an editor, please!

  • Mandy probably smiles in those seductive poses she takes for her profile pic; smirking doesn't really fit the expected expression.
  • Why would Mandy look disrespectful, defiant or bored when she's hanging out with her friends in real life or online?  
I know the CP/QF standard motto is "People who aren't like us are really frantically miserable deep inside" - but that's not coming across in this synopsis at all.


Anytime her mother asks her to help with household chores, Mandy rolls her eyes and stiffens her neck. (Jer. 17:23) Even simple tasks like cleaning her own room or doing her school work throw Mandy into fits of exasperation.

Sadly, Mandy considers her younger siblings a "nuisance". Her youngest sister is always "snooping in her stuff," and her little brother constantly makes the "most annoying noises." None of Mandy's friends get along with their brothers and sisters, so she considers it normal. Besides, rather than spend time with her family, she would much rather watch television, go to the mall, or hang out with her friends. (pg. 70)

The Bible verses shoved in the middle of the description of Mandy are disconcerting and weird.  Most people do not have a compulsion to justify everything they do with a Scripture quote; I assure you that Mandy does not care that she's behaving in a way denigrated in Jeremiah.

Apparently, being told to clean your room and do your homework should be taken with a light heart and bouncy step.  Never mind the fact that most parents have given up on enforcing their level of cleanliness on a teenager's room and that most teenagers are more than capable of doing their homework without nagging.  The term, by the way, is homework.  Mandy did school work while she was at school.

Notice that the problem with Mandy is that she tells the truth about her younger siblings.  Her younger sister is nosy and gets into Mandy's personal items - but the problem in Stacy McDonald's mind is that Mandy wants to enforce a boundary that her sister needs to respect her stuff.   Younger siblings often make annoying noises; children are noisy.  Instead of teaching the little brother to respect the rules of the house - like using "indoor voices" and that some toys are "outdoor toys" - the problem is that Mandy doesn't shut up and let the kids do whatever they want.

Interesting fact: neither watching TV nor going to the mall excludes spending time with family.  In my family, both of these activities are large group activities that involve talking, discussions and time with family members.

Denigrate teens spending time with other teens at your own risk.  Having teenagers participate in fraternal, sororal, or mixed gender groups of age-mates is far more universal and historical than forcing teens to remain in "family-integrated" or "age-integrated" groupings.  Other teenagers are the people Mandy will be forming businesses with, finding a romantic partner from and raising their children along side - not the random older people her parents like to be around.


Mandy is good friends with a lot of guys. One boy in particular follows her around a lot. She finds herself strangely amused when she catches him staring at her. She even made a game of catching his eye and purposely making him blush. Of course he's just a friend to her - if he can't control himself, that's his problem (Proverbs 6:25-26). (pg. 70)

Boy - only CP/QF can make flirting lead directly to sexual sin without any stops along the way.   

Guess what?  Mandy is wayyyy farther along on the track of romance than most married CP/QF adherents.  She's accurately assessed the interest of a peer, decided she's attracted to him and communicates her attraction using nonverbal body language.  Her boy friend managed to get her attention and communicate attraction, too.

The Proverbs quote doesn't apply to this situation.  The Proverb is to avoid an adulterous woman who is propositioning you.  Mandy's not having an affair; all she's done so far is bat her eyes at another teenager.  That's not even fornication let alone adultery.

What stands out even more than Mandy's gloomy makeup and depressing appearance is her lack of dignity - self-respect. She may momentarily enjoy the negative attention she gets from her revealing dress and forward behavior, but it doesn't satisfy her. Instead it leaves her with an empty gnawing in the pit of her stomach. She yearns to feel clean and truly loved. (pg. 70)

Is Mandy supposed to be a "Queen of the Night" style goth - or what?  She's in gloomy makeup, wears her hair over her face, looks generally depressed and is also wearing revealing clothing.  That's a relatively rare look for teenage girls in my area of the US - which is pretty close to Mrs. McDonald's section of the US.

In my experience, teens who dress like goths generally have plenty of dignity and self-respect; it's not a style that brings a ton of positive feedback from others in the world.  It's a clothing style that they like and take a great deal of time and energy to achieve.   I've had two "Goth-like" students who I had for multiple years and developed good rapport with; neither of them ever implied they felt miserable, empty or dirty because of their life choices.  Instead, they had a healthy level of spunk, an ability to hold their own opinions while disagreeing respectfully with others and a fondness for death metal that I found adorable.  The students were also well loved by their family and circle of friends - and actually were the least likely to have children before leaving high school.

Some may agree that the behaviors of girls like modern Mandy is a bit destructive, but is it really that big a deal? After all, isn't it natural for a girl in her teens to want to get away from her family; and isn't everyone irritated by their younger siblings? Isn't this all apart of growing up? "" If it feels right do it!" Isn't that normal? (pg. 70)

None of Mandy's behaviors are destructive.  Posting a flirty, fully dressed picture on the internet is normal.  Spending time with friends in a peer group is normal.  Having romantic interests is normal.  Dressing to fit your peer group is normal.  Believing that no one understands you is so normal.   Finding your siblings annoying is normal.

 What kills me is that CP/QF teens do all the same things - they just do it with a slight twist to fit a different peer group.  Their pictures are in nice Sunday clothes playing with a sibling or niece to show what good parenting material they are.  They do "projects" through their church or home school association.  They gossip incessantly about who is courting whom and who is dressed immodestly.  They make or buy flouncy tea-length skirts with shirts that are tailored - but not showing skin or a figure!  They spend inordinate amounts of time figuring out how they are going to do something amazing for Christ that is completely and totally different than anyone else has done before.  They practice sweeping family conflicts under the rug rather than using communication to change habits.

When push comes to shove, I'd rather spend an afternoon working with Mandy on her science homework than an afternoon with Mrs. McDonald.

Monday, January 1, 2018

Preparing Single Income Sons: Chapter One

A good sales technique involves leading off with an inspirational story that the potential clients can aspire to using the good or service being sold.  Steven Maxwell starts off "Preparing Sons To Provide for a Single Income Family" with an inspiring story about "Troy".

We have known Troy for many years. As a homeschool student in high school, his first job was as a two-week temporary assistant to the most junior employee in the company. Troy was hired to move heavy archive boxes in the basement. Since this was his first real job, Troy determined to do is best regardless of how menial the tasks. Hauling boxes doesn't sound like an impressive start to a career, does it? However, it was amazing to see how God was working. While doing his work assignments, Troy was diligently learning the archiving system of the company. He also tried to perform each task quickly so he would be available to do other "little" things for his boss. (pg. 13)


Translation: Troy had the grunt-level go-fer position that is the best job that most high school students can aspire to.  Oh, sure, it's been dressed up in nicer terms, but I had roughly the same job as a "bagger" or "utility worker" at a local grocery store.  The job pays minimum wage and consists of doing random menial chores like bagging groceries, collecting carts out of the parking lot, and cleaning the bathrooms.

Troy may have been a Christian home schooled dynamo - but any ambitious teenager would behave the same way.   While I was a bagger,  I volunteered to learn any and all tasks that baggers could do.  I used my strong memory skills to learn where items were in the store so that I could work as the floating bagger who would get replacement items when an item had broken in someone's cart.  Additionally, my bosses knew that I was able to work independently on chores without goofing off.   My work ethic and skills impressed my bosses and I was given more responsibilities like working at sorting returns (which is more complicated than it sounds) and sitting in on job interviews.


His temporary position was extended, and after a couple of months, he replaced his " boss" as archiving manager for the company. Throughout the next year or so, he completely redesigned the archive system from the bottom up. This included designing a new database and tracking system for more than 4,000 boxes of information. (pg. 13)


This paragraph made me curious about the size of the company that Troy worked for.  The company has over 4,000 boxes of archived information - but Troy took over the archives department after only a few months on the job.    Was Troy in charge of turning over the archival documents as they were not needed any more?  Was anyone doing that - or is this 20 years worth of old financial records that are taking up space and being a potential security risk?

Designing a new database and tracking system takes a few hours to a few days of work maximum even in the old days of computer systems that weren't as easy to use as modern programs.  The majority of the time involved in changing over an information retrieval system is coding the archives with the new system.   It's tedious as hell - and assuming that the previous system was accurate - can be done by someone with minimal training for fairly low pay.

This is another area I have some personal experience.  I took over a project for a professor that two undergraduates had worked on for several years.   The undergraduates had had excellent lab skills - but their organizational skills were sadly lacking.   On this single project, there were three separate and contradicting coding systems being used on different plant species, tissues and slides.  Equally exasperating for me was the lack of any kind of organizational system for the pucks of paraffin wax that had the plant specimens.  (There were over 300 wax pucks stashed in moving boxes.)

Sorting out the three existing code system took me around 20 hours total.   Creating a code system that did not add any new contradictions while resolving the old contradictions took about 2 hours total.  Planning the system to store the pucks and slides was less than an hour's work.  Cataloging the slides and plant parts in the paraffin along with assigning a code for relative quality of the slide or remaining part took several weeks of full-time work.

What level of work was Troy doing?  Was he sorting the plant bits or archive boxes into the right area - or was he reviewing the material and determining its value?  The first example is a low-paying job that can easily be replaced; the second is the type of skill that can build a career.


Computers have always interested Troy, and he found himself helping various people in the company with small projects in his spare time. While not an expert in formulas or the financial aspects of spreadsheets, his desire to learn enabled him to create, fix, and modify spreadsheets. Thus he began to be used in the process of the converting the company spreadsheet from Lotus 1-2-3 to Microsoft Excel. After a while he was doing spreadsheet and database consulting full-time. He completely redesigned the company's largest financial spreadsheet (which was made up of 17 inter-working spreadsheets) in a 3-month long development project.

Troy began working for minimum wage, and while still in high school his hourly rate had climbed $25 per hour. Our experience has been similar. I have seen that if a young man is prepared properly, he will excel in the workplace. (pgs. 13-14)

The important bits of a spreadsheet are those formulas that help a company keep track of those financial aspects.   If Troy wasn't able to correctly translate the formulas from Lotus 1-2-3 to Microsoft Excel,  that means he was doing basic data entry.  Anyone who can type can do the data entry between two programs - and nowadays there's probably an online file converter that can do the data entry in a tenth of the time.

 I'm confused by the statement that Troy  "redesigned" an entire company's financial spreadsheet when the same paragraph states that Troy's not an expert in business finance.  He may have successfully changed programs or simplified the design somehow - but I'd be very hesitant redesign an entire system in an area that I know very little about.

So - at about Troy's age - I was in college taking an instrumental chemistry class.  The labs for that class often took a month's worth of lab time (and lots of outside of class time) to complete.  To keep track of the data that we collected required spreadsheet documents that contained 20-30 separate inter-working pages.  The main difference is that the spreadsheet was the final project for Troy; for me, the spreadsheet was a tool used to analyze an experiment and make conclusions.   I bring this up because there is a huge hole in Troy's business plan.  He is extremely vulnerable to being replaced by someone who has Troy's computer skills AND business experience as well.

So ends the parable of Troy.  The next two pages are about how nervous parents are about raising sons and how hard it is to make choices about how to educate their sons - but Maxwell has a lot of answers in this book! 

The chapter wraps up with a bunch of character vignettes based off of people Steve really knows.  Three of them stuck with me:

Larry tried college after high school but then quit. He worked in his parents business for several years until it closed. His income averages $100,000 a year as a self-taught programmer. His wife is home full-time with their large family. They give everything that he earns over their needs to missionaries. (pg. 16-17)


This - without meaning to be - is a mirror to what the average CP/QF student faces - and hopes for.  The percentage of Americans who have earned a bachelor's degree by age 40 has been stagnant at around 33% since the end of World War II.  The change has been that far more women and people of color now receive bachelor's degrees than was the case in the 1950's.  Another change is that far more people start - but never finish - undergraduate degrees. 

Many home school students are well-prepared for college - but many CP/QF students face major educational hurdles as well.  Extreme sheltering of teenagers from "controversial" or "humanist" literature means that these students have far more reading to do to keep pace in English or humanities classes.  All of the CP/QF approved science curricula I have seen are lacking the depth and rigor that is expected of a college-prep science curriculum.   Far too many blogs have very detailed explanations of why their kids don't really need advanced math during high school; that kind of thinking leads to students needing multiple remedial courses in college.

This is the first place that noted something about family businesses; roughly 50% of new businesses close within the first five years.  The Maxwell Family has redesigned their business model once and has one defunct business; that's better than the average business odds since they have at least three working businesses by my count.

I'm very curious about how Larry became a self-taught programmer.  Was it something he studied on the side while in college and working in the family business?  Did he take classes?  Did he use his local library? 

I'm also have lots of questions about Larry's business.  How long did it take Larry to reach a point where he averaged $100,000 per year on programming business?  What's the range of his yearly income?  Is that income net or gross?  $100,000 of income sounds like a lot of money - but my total benefits package when I was a teacher was estimated at $64,000 because of the cost of health insurance for my husband and I.  A large family could easily reach $30,000 a year in health insurance costs alone.

I find the mention of giving their "extra" money to missionaries grating.  There's no reason to go telling the world how a family chooses to give to different non-profits.

Eric had his own graphic design business for 2 years. He loved throwing his heart into making it successful. Unfortunately, he would have starved had he not been living with his parents. His father wanted to teach Eric programming, But Eric only had eyes for graphic design and wasn't interested. (pg. 17)


Pretty sure "Eric" is Steven Maxwell's second son Christopher.  From what I've read on the Maxwell's blog and books, Nathan does everything correctly while Christopher does nothing right.   Nathan transitioned smoothly from home school to a career to a business of his own; Christopher refused to follow the exact same path and hasn't been as successful career wise.  Nathan (and eventually Joseph and John) managed to save up enough money to buy a home within walking distance of Steve and Teri's house in their early to mid-twenties.  Christopher put off buying a house until the geriatric age of 29!  Near as I can tell, the only thing his parents have approved of is his choice of wife who has provided them with about one grand-kid every 18 months since they married.

Steve has an electrical engineering degree. He spent 20 years in good corporate jobs. The last three years of his corporate work, Steve's oldest, homeschooled son, who have not gone to college, earned a significantly larger salary than his father. (pg. 17)

The effect Steve's story is supposed to have on a reader: "Wow!  My kid can out-earn an electrical engineer right out of college if we follow Steve's advice!"

The effect the story had on me the first time I read it: "What the hell happened to Steve's career?  Something went seriously awry for him if his degree-free kid was out earning him..."

In the last post, I laid out what I think happened based on information available online.  Steve Maxwell worked for an aerospace company that lost a major defense contract.  By the time Nathan graduated home school, Maxwell's employer was in a death spiral.   It's completely possible that Steve Maxwell wasn't working full-time by the time that Nathan started working at Western Auto; a part-time compromise would have saved his employer a great deal on salary and benefits while allowing Steve to start his fledgling printing and computer forms business.  With Maxwell's experience and contacts, starting a business in the Kansas City area would have allowed his growing family to avoid another cross-country move.  Being self-employed would also burnish his growing credentials as a leader in the CP/QF movement.  (I can never remember if the Maxwell's are ATI, Vision Forum or independent....)

Well, that's the end of the first chapter.  Next chapter talks about the qualities that determine the earning potential of a job.

Friday, December 29, 2017

Preparing Single Income Sons: Spinning Stories for Sale

The Maxwell Family - of Titus2.com fame - have a fair number of publications to their name. 

Teri Maxwell's family, school and chore organizational blockbusters of "Managers of Their Homes", "Managers of Their Chores" and "Managers of Their Schools" seem to be a perennial favorite among large families.  She's also written "Homeschooling With a Meek and Quiet Spirit" which I reviewed here.

Her daughter Sarah has written ten children's books that are completely free of any objectionable material at all!  (I can't bring myself to read them - the free PDF chapters on the website made me feel like I was in the first part of a dysutopian novel.)

This lead me to Steven Maxwell's book "Preparing Sons to Provide for a Single Income Family".  Truthfully, I was curious what he recommended - and if his advice matched my experiences in preparing students for the workforce.   

The odd thing I wasn't expecting, though, was that his book felt like I was reading two separate stories at the same time. 

The official "story" goes as follows:  Steven Maxwell works for 20 years in corporate America after receiving a college degree in engineering - but God was calling him to start his own business.  Meanwhile,  his son Nathan who was home schooled and has not attended college was out-earning Steven during Steven's last few years in the corporate world through grit, hard-work, and (the implication of) contract work alone.  If Nathan Maxwell can jump economically that far ahead of his father through online certifications and a home-business, anyone can!

It's a great story - and I bet it's sold a bunch of $15.00 paperback books over the years.  The real story is more complicated - and a more realistic view at how career connections can be passed on from one generation to the next.

I haven't been able to run down all of Steven Maxwell's previous employers - but he mentions having served in the Air Force for four years prior to being saved on the family blog. 

  • He earned a Bachelor Degree in Applied Science in Electrical and Electronics Engineering from the University of Missouri in Rolla in 1979 according to his LinkedIn profile.  
  •  In "Preparing Sons...", he mentions working for an unnamed company in marketing followed by sales before leaving the company in 1986 for Boeing on page 34.  
  • According to his LinkedIn profile, he worked at Wilcox / Thompson (sic) CSF from 1990-1997 as a procurement engineer.  (I'm assuming he means Wilcox Electric / Thomson CSF - a major electrical company during that time in Kansas City) 
This means that by 1996, Steven Maxwell had a long list of contacts in a variety of engineering firms that he could use for starting his own business and helping his sons launch their own companies.
In 1996, Wilcox Electric lost a large defense contract that crippled the company.  I don't know if that's what Steve refers to as a call from God to start his own company - but it was extremely prudent of Steve to look at other options for supporting his family.  I think "Preparing Sons...." mentions that Steve's original plan was that Communication Concepts, Inc was going to provide printing and electronic forms - but I could be wrong about that.  

When I compared Nathan Maxwell's LinkedIn profile, I was surprised - although hardly shocked - to realize that his first listed job was at Wilcox Electric in 1996 working on the company's computer servers.  

Nathan left that position in 1997 to work at Western Auto for nearly three years in their information technology department where he ran some pretty intense systems.

By 1999, Communication Concepts, Inc was running strongly enough to support at least Nathan and Steven.

The real story is pretty darn cool - and nothing that needs to be hidden.  Steven Maxwell used training through the military and college to provide for his family for 20 years and had the business acumen to start a fledgling business when his original career area hit a major recession.  His son Nathan had the right experience in computers to land a series of solid jobs that gave him the experience to become an computer security expert in his own right.

The only problem is that "Preparing Sons..." sells a fantastic world that doesn't represent the actual way that the Maxwell Family has reached their well-earned success.


Wednesday, December 27, 2017

Maidens of Virtue: Chapter Six

 Blogs are a fascinating view into the mind of the author.  I feel like I learn a lot about an author's personality both by the stories they chose to include and the spin they place on the stories.  Technically, "Maidens of Virtue" by Stacy McDonald is a book - but we get revealing glimpses into how her mind works through her anecdotes.

Chapter Six is titled "Baby's Got Her Blue Jeans On".  The chapter serves two purposes.  First, Stacy McDonald makes it clear that public schools are hot-beds of social judgement and sexual harassment that would crush the gentle, delicate flowers of CP/QF maidenhood.  The second purpose is to make young women extremely self-conscious about how their clothing could be construed by random strange males.

I find both of the purposes repugnant and irresponsible for an adult woman to pile onto pre-teen and teenage girls - and I do not like the glimpses of Mrs. McDonald that appear in this chapter.

To most people, blue jeans are as "American" as apple pie. Whether they're straight leg or boot-cut, bell bottom or "skinny", many people - - especially young people - - place great value on a pair of well fitting jeans. When I was in my teens, a girl was considered a "nobody" if she didn't have at least one pair of tight fitting, designer jeans --preferably Gloria Vanderbilts (topped off with a gold stretch belt - -don't ask). (pg. 61)

Wednesday, December 20, 2017

Maidens of Virtue: Chapter Five

There is a one thing I really enjoyed about this chapter.  It is really short.

The rest of the chapter is a vapid, contradictory ramble on how people should dress modestly because otherwise those lost pagans might not think the right things about Jesus!  Also, Christians shouldn't judge others by their outer appearances - but Christians can TOTALLY judge people by their outer appearances.

It's so tricky to justify judging others while being totally clear that you yourself are not to be judged.

The chapter leads off with a completely unconvincing "discussion" between two friends about how Hannah thinks Sarah's clothing is inappropriate.

"But it doesn't matter what I wear!" Sarah scoffed. "God sees my heart!" Sarah finish putting on her lipstick while Hannah tried in vain to reason with her old friend.

" Yes, God sees your heart," Hannah explained, " but nobody else does --especially boys --they see that." Hannah swept her hand in front of Sarah's revealing outfit. "Don't you see? They're too distracted by what you're wearing to notice you."

"But that's my point! I don't care if boys notice me or not." Hannah smiled coyly. "I just care what God thinks, and he can see my heart." (pg. 53)

Wednesday, December 13, 2017

Homeschooling with a Meek and Quiet Spirit: Depression - Part One

This is the second to last post on Teri Maxwell's "Homeschooling with a Meek and Quiet Spirit".  She has an entire chapter dedicated to discussing her personal struggles with depression and strategies that worked for her.  I've decided to divide the chapter into two posts.  This post is about non-toxic strategies.  The last post will be about toxic strategies.

Let's dive in at the beginning of the chapter.

In one of Steve's monthly home school in articles for dads ( www.titus 2.com; July 2000), he mentioned that my bouts of depression were part of the reason we decided, at one point, to limit our family size. We were amazed at how many people emailed us, after that one sentence in his article, to ask how we dealt with the problem of depression. (pg. 95)

Wow.  I've discussed tangentially my concerns about mental health issues in CP/QF families before - but the fact that the Maxwells' had a wave of emails in response to a single sentence mention of Teri's struggle with depression is sobering.  In the wider US society, there is still lingering stigma about mental health issues - although lessened for the "acceptable" illnesses of depression and anxiety.   By comparison to CP/QF society, the rest of the US lives in a wonderland - a land where medical and psychological remedies exist to lessen the burden of mental illness.  In CP/QF land, all of the asinine assumptions about mental illness exist along with a heap of guilt because if a person REALLY loved God, they wouldn't have mental illness.  (If my options for reasons I have a mental illness is a) not enough faith or b) demonic possession, I think I'd pick the demonic possession.  The fact I'm not entirely to blame for the demon picking on me could be comforting.)

It is only been this 8 years since the Lord has given me freedom from the at times devastating depression from which I had struggled. It was usually worse during the year I nursed a baby. My pain through those difficult years was very real and is not that distant. I can fully understand the concerned feelings of a mom who is struggling with times of depression and the worry of her husband, because that was my experience too. (pg 95-96)

That's a classic description of postpartum depression; it begins within the year after a child is born and can be worsened by the hormonal changes that accompany lactation.   During the years (late 1970's through the late 1990's) that Teri Maxwell was having children, doctors tended to take an overly hard line against the use of anti-depressants during pregnancy and lactation.  Now, doctors have realized that use of most SSRIs during pregnancy has no increased risk of birth defects in the infants while decreased depression symptoms lead to better pregnancy outcomes since the mother is more likely to seek prenatal care and take better care of herself during pregnancy.  In a similar vein, doctors have found that the amount of most SSRIs found in breast milk is nearly none. 

Personally, I remained on an SSRI during my pregnancy with my son and increased the dose slightly after he was born prematurely.  I checked with the neonatal staff and they said that there are very few drugs that are incompatible with breastfeeding - and most of those are contraindicated during pregnancy so I had no reason to worry.

Postpartum depression has been shown to be very treatable through psychological therapy methods as well.  I see a therapist and was extremely grateful for her support during my son's early days.


We discovered that there were very real hormonal imbalances that affected my emotions. I would do everything I could to deny this, but it was obvious to everyone except me. What I could normally handle one day would send me to tears another day. To combat this physical imbalance, I used a natural progesterone cream for a time. In addition, I followed a vitamin regimen suggested by our naturopathic doctor friend. I eliminated caffeine as well. (pg. 97)

Here's my PSA for the week: do NOT use cosmetic creams that contain progesterone - EVER. 

There is a terrifying loophole I learned about while doing background research for this post: as long as a skin preparation is for "cosmetic" purposes, the FDA cannot screen it as it would a skin preparation for "medical purposes".    This means that a cream may contain less progesterone than is advertised - or more.   

Progesterone passes through the skin with relative ease; it has a non-polar structure that is soluble in the lipids that make up the skin.  CP/QF folk already argue that hormonal birth control is evil - and horrible for women's health.  Well, while I was pumping for my son I was on Nora-Be as a birth control method.  It contains a daily oral dose of 0.35 mg of progestin.  For the life of me, I can't remember if Nora-Be was a 21 active day or 28 active day pill - but I received either 7.35 mg or 9.8 mg of progestin per cycle.    Many of the skin creams advertise that they contain 445 mg of progesterone in 2 oz.  Assuming 25% of the progesterone in the cream makes it into the blood stream (which is very conservative), a woman would need to make that 2 oz of cream last for 12 months to keep her hormonal exposure under the amount in a mini-pill like Nora-Be. 

If you think you have a hormonal imbalance that needs to be treated, you need to be seeing an MD, DO, PA, or FNP on a regular basis.

Thankfully, she does have some recommendations that are sane:

Daily exercise was critical at this time. I know daily exercise sounds impossible to an already depressed, overwhelmed, terribly tired mom. My walks were about the only time I was away from home. When I began to feel myself spiraling down, getting out would be the single thing that would change the course of my emotions. Just being away from the environment I was struggling with for a short period each day, plus the effect of the exercise itself, was very helpful (pg. 97-98)

Exercise is huge for my personal sanity.  When Spawn first came home from the NICU, he was a mellow baby who had complicated medical needs.  Going for a walk every day kept me sane.  I needed some time out of the house where I could be away from listening for alarms while scheduling appointments, doing physical therapy with him or caring for him or his equipment.  That mental break boosted the stress-relieving and mood-lightening effects that exercise has for me - plus being outside is very calming for me.

What I was more struck by is how much Teri Maxwell struggled with the entire concept of a SAHM who home schooled to boot.  She doesn't describe struggling with herself nearly as often as she describes struggling with the environment or feelings produced by her environment - and that's a sad commentary on what life must have been like for her.

Being tired was sure to put me off balance. I am a light sleeper, often being awakened in the night by a noise or perhaps the need to nurse a baby. After that, I wouldn't be able to go back to sleep. For 8 years now, I have worn earplugs when I sleep. They have transformed my nights! I thought not being able to sleep was just part of my physical makeup. Not so! Since I began wearing earplugs, I hardly ever have a sleepless night. Steve became the "ears" for our family. I know he will wake me up if the children need me.(Earplugs may not be an option for a mom whose husband can't do this.) (pg. 98)

I have been wearing earplugs for around 15 years now and I sleep much better with them.  Some people are simply wired to respond strongly to noises in the night.  Having earplugs in mutes out a lot of the repetitive noises in the night like the furnace kicking on or the random sounds of cars driving by at night while still letting high pitched noises like fire alarms and human voices make it through.

At the risk of being overly nit-picky, her youngest child was 4 or 5 when this book was written.  Little Mary was more than capable of waking her mom up by shaking her shoulder if she needed her to wake up.  Likewise, if my son is really upset at night - like starts to cry loudly instead of sleep whimpers - I can hear him through my earplugs.

I have another revolutionary idea as well: Steve can deal with most -if not all - of the family's needs at night if he wakes up!  Crazy!

I think if depression-prone moms could figure out a way to work on even a skeleton of a schedule, it would help. I have had moms write to me that when they are depressed, brain-dead, or just overwhelmed, their schedule directed them through the day. This was especially helpful because they couldn't make decisions themselves. If you have somewhat of a schedule in place, despite tiredness or feelings, many things would be accomplished because that is the easiest path to take - just do what the schedule says! Without my schedule on those bad days, I would have simply sat and cried. That would have made everything even worse because then I would have been a day behind! In addition, you can let your schedule direct your children when you don't have the energy to keep up with what you wish you would like to be doing. At least they are accomplishing things rather than just undoing everything. (pgs. 102-103)

Schedules have helped me when I was depressed - but I tend to have an internal schedule naturally when I am not depressed.  Trying to institute a schedule while depressed or overwhelmed by external events may work - but it should be undertaken slowly and gently.  Add one item a day like "Eat breakfast" or "Go for a walk".   This is NOT a good time to purchase the Maxwell's "Managers of Their Home" system and try it for the first time.

I feel bad that Teri Maxwell cannot articulate how angry she felt being at home with her kids.  Oh, she has a chapter devoted to anger - but she never fully owns that being a homeschooling SAHM drove her batty.  Instead, it slips out in bits and smidgens like when she describes how her kids just destroy everything when left unscheduled.....

The last post in this series will be about some spiritual methods of combating depression that sound completely worthless to me.   The next book to be reviewed will be her husband's book "Preparing Sons to Be Single-Income Earners" - in which you can help me try to figure out what kind of career path Steve Maxwell has had.....

Monday, December 4, 2017

Homeschooling With a Meek and Quiet Spirit: Help at Home from Husband

In the two previous posts on "Homeschooling With a Meek and Quiet Spirit" by Terri Maxwell, she's outlined how feeling overwhelmed by doing all the cleaning, cooking, laundry and homeschooling is the fault of your mother for not teaching you how to keep a home while leading you to expecting free time. 

Personally, my solution to this problem is two-fold.  First, I'm planning to let paid educational professional educate my kids - while I educate other people's kids.  I get the irony - but I do best with secondary and post-secondary students learning science so my son will get a much more enjoyable and well rounded education from men and women who want to teach kids.  Second, my husband helps out with our son before he goes to work and in the evenings when he is home along with helping out with home chores.

I can't even pretend I've created a revolutionary solution here; I'm modeling what my parents did when we were young.  Alas, I've apparently been lead horribly astray in expecting that my husband would be an active participant in our family life.

I wonder how the scenario causes you to feel. You've been busy all day homeschooling, getting some laundry done, had an hour of cleaning, made all the meals, and now dinner is over. Your husband heads for his easy chair in the living room and kicks back with the newspaper, while you head to the kitchen to clean up after dinner.(pg. 90)

Friday, November 17, 2017

Homeschooling with A Meek and Quiet Spirit: Reasonable Expectations, Consequences, and Emotional Boundaries

I've reviewed several books on this blog - and the theme connecting the books is absolutely terrible advice. 

We've heard Debi Pearl's idea that girls should learn to make cheese because they might marry a dairy farmer who needs a wife who can make cheese.  (I've still not found an real-life situation where a woman who married in saved a dairy farm because of her cheese-making skills.)  The Botkin Sisters' advice to never show interest in a guy prior to his asking permission to court from your father is pretty atrocious.  Sarah Mally's worst advice was holding the Princess' life as being a shining example of Christian living when a better description would be nearly-terminal-ennui.

From that background,  I had a nice surprise in "Homeschooling with a Meek and Quiet Spirit" by Teri Maxwell.  She has some good advice in the chapter on "Anger" that could save parents and children a lot of strife:

Consider for a moment a sin or habit that you have been praying about and would like to see changed. Here is a simple example from my life. A few years ago, Steve said he would like me to put a cookie sheet under the electric fry pan so that the heat from the fry pan would it damage the kitchen counter. High goal for Mom, but shouldn't be too tough, since she likes to please her husband and surely doesn't want to burn her countertop. However, Mom has never put the cookie sheet under the fry pan in all her life! She is usually preoccupied when working in the kitchen and finds herself forgetting, time after time, to put that cookie sheet in place. I did not want to forget. I did not purpose to ignore my husband's request. I just didn't think about it!

Monday, November 6, 2017

Homeschooling with a Meek and Quiet Spirit - Magical Hubands

I like my husband.  He's a sweet, caring man who is bright and a good listener.  We suit each other well.  I don't like change much - so his love of new experiences pushes me out of my comfort zone.  He struggles with planning and organization outside of his job - so my skills in keeping our life organized makes our home pleasant place to live.  Most importantly, we enjoy each other's company and know how to support each other during hard times.

On the other hand,  neither of us abdicates responsibility entirely to the other person.  I don't ask my husband for input on how I handle grocery shopping or when to schedule Jack's medical appointments; that's my realm of expertise.  Likewise, my husband doesn't expect me to tell him how to fix the well; he's been doing that since he was a teen and I honestly have no experience in that area.

With that background, I hope you understand why the next quote from "Homeschooling with a Meek and Quiet Spirit" scared the snot out of me:
Instead of fearing you are failing in an aspect of your homeschooling, trust that if you are truly failing, your husband will become aware of it and point it out. (pg. 54)

Wednesday, November 1, 2017

Before You Meet Prince Charming: Mel's Epilogue


(Author's note: This is how I see the Princess' early married life unfolding.  Since removing the anachronisms would require writing an entirely new book, I decided to let them remain - and add a few of my own. )

Night Before Princess' Wedding
The Princess languidly watches the moon rise as she rests in the deep casement window of her bedroom.  Tomorrow she begins her real life - a life of joy,  ecstatic love and complete fulfilment as Sir Valiant's wife.

The Queen silently enters her daughter's room.  Even in the most private of moments, her regal bearing and unyielding gaze mark her as separate.

The Princess starts.  "Mother.  I didn't expect to see..."

The Queen's gesture silences her.  "On the night before I married your father, my mother gave this to me.  To honor her memory, I pass the gift on to you."

"Oh, how lovely!  Lady Gloria gave this to you?"

"Yes.  My mother was a flawed woman, I am sorry to say.  She was full of ...wrong...ideas. My mother never learned the beauty of submission to her husband much to my shame.  This pendant was her "insurance policy" for my future - a bauble for me to exchange for cash if my husband ever led me into dire times.  As I said, she was foolish and misguided - but she was my mother.  I believe she would want you to have it now."

"Thank you, Mother.  I will cherish it."

"I am glad you have it - although you will not need an insurance policy.  Goodnight, my daughter. "

Two harvests after the wedding:
"...and that will get the People ready to fight Temptation!" Valiant finished triumphantly.

The Princess started awake.  Quickly, she glanced at her husband lying next to her in bed to see if he had noticed.  Blessedly, he hadn't.

"Oh, darling!  That plan is entirely what God intended for the Kingdom.  How lucky the Kingdom is to have a brave knight like you to plan and initiate protection programs against Lies and Temptation."

Valiant glowed at his wife's praise.  "What did you do today?"

"I had the servants move the furnishings of the West Wing again. This time it is just perfect! ......   Oh! The Alligator had the most absurd idea yet.  Shall I tell you about it?"

"I wait with bated breath."

"The Alligator wanted me to be out amongst the People more!  Can you imagine?  I explained to him that you were the heir apparent and that the People needed to see you as the future King.  The People need to learn to follow you - not your wife.  My role is to demonstrate the proper submission of wife to husband just as the Kingdom will model submission of subject to king."

"Well done, darling.  You need not worry yourself over the affairs of the Kingdom.  That's....my burden...." Valiant drifted off to sleep.

The Princess shifted, unable to shake her feeling of unease.  She had wanted a husband who saw the great struggles in life and fought them.  She had wanted to be his helper and accomplish more in the Name of God than any had before. 

God had given her everything she wanted - so why did she feel empty? 

A good God-fearing wife wouldn't fall asleep while he described his newest plan - let alone question the wisdom of the plan in her heart.   

Giving herself a good shake, she resolved to try harder tomorrow to be the wife that Valiant deserved.

The next day
The Princess wandered aimless through the castle.  She found herself standing in the sweltering sunlight by the moat.

"Good morning, Princess."

"Good morning, Alligator.  My husband and I agreed that your concerns over my presence in the Kingdom are overblown and absurd - as always."

"I am sorry to hear that.  I fear you are making a grave mistake.  The People love you because you represent security - a Kingdom that prospers under stability and peace."

The Princess threw her hair back dismissively.  "They will love my husband as well!".

"The People already know your husband.  Sir Valiant is a common-born man who has contrived to become the next king.  Mind you, I like that about him.  It shows he has ambition.  But he has not ascended to the throne yet.  He needs the gloss of your nobility next to him to make the people forget who he was..."

"Alligator!  I know I am right!"

The Alligator looked at the slim figure standing above him.  The Princess' artless understanding of human nature grated on him.  And the King married her to Sir Valiant - a callow windbag!    The Alligator took a deep breath and tried again.

"My informants tell me the harvest for this year is poor.  Many in the Kingdom fear Famine and Disease will ride again."

"And I told you, Alligator, that my husband knows the important enemies of Lies and Temptation ride now.  We cannot lose sight of the enemies before us in preparation for something that may never happen."

"Sir Diomed and his wife Lady Sophia are providing supplies of grain and roots to local villagers already."

"Diomed is my cousin.  He's Uncle Justheart's younger son.  Of course,  he would help our Kingdom."

"Princess!" the Alligator hissed.  "Open your eyes before it is too late. Diomed is cunning - and hungers to see himself on a throne.  Your husband is scorned by the nobility.  The knights of the Kingdom mock him as a coward.  Neither will rise to support Valiant's claim to the Kingdom's throne if Diomed challenges him.  The People love you - but they will love the man who stands between their families and starvation more. "

The Princess stepped backwards in anger.  "I'm sure I have no idea what you are talking about, scum eater!" she spat before escaping into the castle.

The Alligator tail-slapped the water in frustration.  "I EAT GOATS!" he yelled at the pitiless sun burning above.  Sliding back to the bottom of the moat, he chewed on a fat haunch of a wether while pondering his next line of argument.  His lineage had pledged to protect and serve the Royal Family in time past.  He knew his duty; he hoped he could convince the Princess of hers before it was too late.

Four winters after the wedding
The Princess woke from a fitful sleep.  She checked on little Phoebe huddled under a worn blanket on her pallet.  Rising, the Princess tucked her threadbare comforter around her small daughter to keep her warm in the cold night.

She paced silently through the halls questioning how her life had reached this point.  She had been separate from the sinful world.  She bent her will to the will of her father, the King.  At great personal cost, she had been pure and chaste.  Her life was supposed to reflect the gladness, ease and joy that came from an unsullied girlhood.  Her marriage to the righteous Sir Valiant would spark a rebirth of Godly values in the Kingdom which would shine as a beacon of holiness through the land.

Their shared dream propelled them forward through the last years they lived in the Kingdom

The second winter after her marriage Famine and Disease moved into the Kingdom.  Diomed and Sophia's food supplies prevented Starvation from entering - but the People struggled.  Disease preyed on the weakened populace.

Cosseted by her family's wealth and preoccupied with the impending birth of her first child, the People's despair went unnoticed by the Princess.  Her father and husband spoke of the benefits that suffering would bring to the People - "iron sharpening iron" for the battle against Lies and Temptation.

Phoebe was born that summer as the crops ripened in the field and the People hoped for enough to survive the coming winter.  Sir Valiant rejoiced in his newborn daughter before departing on a mission for the King the day after her birth.  He and the King had decided that the time was right to train up young men to fight Lies and Temptation.

Valiant returned three months later jubilant in his success of training up a small, select group of believers. The Princess was proud of her husband's success towards their vision for the Kingdom.  She hid her grief over Phoebe's discomfort in the arms of her husband and never admitted to anyone that she rarely missed Valiant during their time apart.  She commiserated with her husband that his newly trained force mistakenly placed the worldly concern of harvesting crops over moving forward immediately on their mission.

The downfall of the Royal Family began with a slow, steady rain a week before the grains were ripe.  When the rain stopped, the temperature soared higher than all but the oldest People remembered.  The elderly farmers warned of grains cooking in the fields and a starvation winter.

Valiant brought that folk-tale back to the castle for the Royal Family's amusement.  How could grain cook in a field?  The People were so gullible. 

The grain crops failed.  Famine gripped the land.  Diease moved through the People.  Baby Phoebe sickened, but survived.  Her grandparents did not.

Heartbroken, the Princess and Sir Valiant greeted Sir Diomed who came to offer his condolences - and assume the throne.  As foreseen by the Alligator, the hearts and minds of the People had been won over by Sir Diomed who brought safety and salvation in the form of food. 

Sir Diomed and Lady Sophia had no reason to harm the small remnant of the Royal Family.  In fact, they had prepared a place for them in the court at Carnalville. 

There the Princess languished.  She sought to educate the people about their faulty religious beliefs - and found she could not articulate her own beliefs.  The Princess demonstrated her hard-won skills of baking, painting, goldsmithing, weaving and dyeing - and found that impartial observers found her skills to be poor.  She wanted to capture the hearts of the court for Christ - but found that she could not capture the attention of the people at court.

Hardest of all, the Princess realized that there was no companionship in her marriage.  Valiant thrived on creating large dreams.  Trapped as an inconsequential member of a foreign court, Valiant escaped by dreaming of the days when God's Plans - as shown to Valiant - would succeed and he would reign over a God-fearing Kingdom. 

There was no place in this dream for a grieving wife and a tiny daughter in small, cold rooms. 

More alone than ever before,  Princess rested against the cold wall and wondered what the future held.

Wednesday, October 25, 2017

Homeschooling with a Meek and Quiet Spirit: Phonics Frenzy

This section came from a chapter on anxiety. 

Mrs. Maxwell's premise is that telling others what to do is anxiety-provoking while following orders is anxiety relieving. 

I don't agree with the premise at all. 

I never feel particularly anxious when I tell others what to do because I give orders when I believe that I have information that will be helpful to accomplishing a task.  When I was helping with an autumn olive removal work crew, I gave some suggestions on how we could use the tools and people available to remove the most plants as possible in a short time period.   On the other side, I get nervous when someone tells me to do something that doesn't seem like it will work out well.

Mrs. Maxwell takes this questionable premise and adds a religious twist:
In a very similar way, when I can view myself as simply following the Lord's orders, then I don't have to own the responsibility for the outcome. When this is true, many of the fears and worries vanish. (pg. 49)
*blinks*

This is a strangely un-Biblical idea - and certainly un-Christian.  Does her Bible have Matthew 25? You know - the wise and foolish bridesmaids? The parable of the talents?  Dividing the sheep and goats?   The Bible makes it's pretty clear that Christians are expected to make choices and live with the consequences.

After laying this warped framework out, she dives into how it plays out in a homeschool setting.

It may be that you have begun your six-year-old on a phonics program, but it is going poorly at best. You start to worry that the phonics program was not a wise investment, or that your child has some kind of learning disability. How can you regain a meek and quiet spirit in this situation? You can take your thoughts captive and remember several things.

First, you prayed about your choice of a phonics program, and the Lord led you to this one. Secondly, much is learned in homeschooling aside from the actual targeted "academics." Perhaps the Lord has in mind some other learning through this problem. (pg. 49)

*rubs head*
Let's attack this from an educational standpoint where we accept that the goal is to teach the six-year old phonics first and see if that solves the problem before requesting Divine intervention.

With that goal, the cost of the investment is moot unless the program is completely inflexible.  (Hint: no program is completely inflexible because 30% of teaching is learning how to adapt materials to fit the students.)

Next, I brainstormed all the reason that a phonics program may not be doing well.  I ordered them from "most common" to "least common" based on my experience teaching HS students.  (I would love feedback from people on their experiences!)

  • The teacher is learning the new program.
  • The student is still figuring out the new program.
  • The program's methods are a poor fit for the student who is progressing normally.
  • The program-student interface is fine but teacher expectations are too high.
  • The student is not developmentally ready for phonics.
  • The student has a learning disability.
Honestly, if the program has just begun, the best solution for the parent-teacher to spend more time to get comfortable with the program while observing their kid's response to the program.  Give the program at least 10 contact hours (that would be about 2 weeks in traditional schools) to let the newness wear off before making any decisions.

If progress is still slow, try and adapt an activity.  Maybe the kid needs something more active like making the sound of the day out of play-dough or tracing it in shaving cream.  Grab a dry-erase marker and do the lesson on a window or mirror.  Pull out the Scrabble tiles and see how many words - real and imaginary - that the student can make with that sound.  Give creative options at least 5 contact hours to work.

Still not working?  Your kid may not be ready for phonics yet.  I'm assuming that the kid has mastered the sounds of the alphabet for both the capital and lower-case letters and can sight-read some common words.  If not, the program may be too advanced for your six-year old - and six is a bit young for detailed phonics lessons.  Keep working on basic reading and try again in a month or two.  (The freedom to focus instruction exactly to the student the biggest benefit of homeschooling, IMHO.  The biggest drawback is that the parent-teacher would need to track 4 subject areas multiplied by the number of kids they have...that adds up quick!)

Learning disabilities are more common than many people think - but the diagnosis should be done by a trained educational professional.  The local or regional school district employs professionals who do this for a living.  If you think your student has a learning disability, consider strongly re-enrolling the student in public schools for diagnosis purposes at least.   (Most public school teachers have a story about a home schooled student who was re-enrolled because the parent-teacher decided slow progress in an area was due to a learning disability...except that the slow progress was remedied in a classroom without special education services. The parent had been doing everything right - the kid simply performed better in a setting away from home.)

Regarding God's Plan - maybe the lesson is to be humble in regards to the decisions we make or to be diligent in carrying out the responsibilities shouldered by the parent-teacher.  


Maybe this is an opportunity for your child to learn to persevere through something that doesn't come easily for him. It could be that this is a time for you to develop the added patience while you gently and sweetly work with your child every day, even though the progress isn't visible. Rather than giving in to fear and worry, spend time with the Lord and your husband discerning if there are "bigger" learning projects in this trial that a 6 year old who isn't "getting it". Face your concerns with a meek and quiet spirit! (pg. 49-50)

Perseverance is an excellent "soft" skill to cultivate in children - but the goal that the child is expected to reach must be reasonable or else the child learns that hard work leads to nothing but frustration and despair.

Likewise, teachers must be patient and capable of regulating their own emotions.  They also have to judge the capacity of a student to learn the material.  I co-taught Chemistry with a certified special education teacher for two years; it was one of the best experiences of my teaching career.  I had one student who has a documented severe learning disability in reading combined with a mild cognitive issue.  Teaching him to find information on the Periodic Table took a great deal of patience and gentle humor to keep his spirits up -and it was amazing to see his pride when he mastered that skill. 

Now, I still possessed patience and humor when the class reached balancing equations - plus I had a strong relationship with the student - but that task proved to be beyond his capability.   He tried hard, I tried hard, my co-teacher worked like a demon - but balancing required a level of abstract thinking that was a step too far for the student.  We let that concept go and created a chemistry-based skill that was achievable for him.

Mrs. Maxwell has a strange faith in her husband's ability to suss out the problems in her home school from afar.  This theme reappears later in the book - but how does that work?  Mr. Maxwell was working full-time as an electrical engineer; he wasn't observing the dynamics in the school or the way his children were learning.  I'm sure he could give excellent emotional support but I'd be a bit leary of substituting a soft skill goal in lieu of learning phonics.

Oh, well.  I'm watching my son amuse himself on the floor while I write this.  He's playing with a plastic toy and he seems to be in the very first stages of using a pincer grasp.  When he was 4 months adjusted, I took a toy off his play-gym that was a plastic maze that had beads that could be maneuvered along the lines of plastic.  I did that because he would reach out for the beads with his fully extended fingers,  try to move the beads with his rigid fingers, fail repeatedly and begin to cry/scream with frustration.  Rather than face 5 months of a frustrated infant, I put the toy away.   Now that he's approaching readiness at 7.5 months adjusted, I'm going to put the toy back.  The toy might be a little frustrating now - but a little frustration is manageable.

ETA: Little guy is off oxygen 24/7 now - and has started hard-core rolling.  Time to child-proof everything.

Monday, October 23, 2017

Before You Meet Prince Charming: Epilogue - Part Two

We've reached the shining pinnacle of "Before You Meet Prince Charming" - Sir Valiant and the Princess are safely married and are allowed to have an emotional and sexual relationship.

That would be less concerning if they had a platonic relationship prior to engagement and marriage.  Heck, I'd feel better if I knew that they knew each other better than they know the cashier at the local grocery store.

This is most of the conversation.  I cut out a few sections where Valiant and Princess cattily bash the Alligator.  The Alligator is interesting and incisive; the model humans are not.

The moon was bright and a cool breeze kissed the cheeks of the princess and Sir Valiant as they sat talking in the Royal Garden. They had just arrived home from their honeymoon and although they were a little worn out from the trip, they were as excited as ever. It was a peaceful evening, with no noise but the crickets chirping and the leaves rustling in the wind. (pg. 245)

Monday, October 16, 2017

Before You Meet Prince Charming: Epilogue - Part One

I noticed while preparing for this post that the chapters of the book end BEFORE the Princess and Sir Valiant begin courting.  I suppose that's a stylistic choice based on the title of book and - perhaps - a dislike of ending on Chapter 13.

Personally, I'm still freaked out by the King's interpretation that Sir Valiant was asking to marry the Princess when Sir Valiant asked what qualities the King would be looking for in a suitor for the Princess.

Anyway, the King wanders off to tell the Princess that Sir Valiant, the King, and the Queen are all in favor of the Princess dating sorry, "courting" Sir Valiant.

As always, the Princess is off doing critically important stuff!

Returning from one of her frequent trips to the various villages where she joyfully and kindly met the needs of many who were fainthearted, poor, injured, and troubled. Today she had paid a special visit to her friend Maiden Flirtelia and had given counsel and encouragement to a girl named Simplicity whom she had met along the way. She also visited a sick mother and played with her children, gave some fabric to a needy family, and delivered a personal letter from her father to a village nobleman. The princess was learning again and again that it is more blessed to give than to receive. The more she delighted in her heavenly Prince, the more she wanted to share with others the fulfillment she had in Him. (pgs. 239, 241)
To recap, the Princess visited a friend, pontificated to a random kid who she'd never met before, provided minimal help to a sick woman, gave a raw material to another family and acted as a page.

 Whoo-hoo!  She managed to do two activities that Jesus wanted his followers in one afternoon.  That's a 40% return on her afternoon activities!

More seriously,  the Princess has power as a member of the Royal Family that she is squandering.  While not as powerful as a reigning monarch or the male heir to the throne, a sole daughter of marriageable age would have access to some money as well as great influence over the activities of noble families.  The Princess could be endowing orphanages,  establishing storehouses to supply goods to needy commoners or funding hospitals.  Instead, she's puttering around doing what she likes to do (e.g., play with kids) and giving away items she's finished as a hobby (e.g., fabric) and pretending that she's doing good works.

Notice as well that the Princess spends more time around children or alone than she does around people her own age or adults.  In my mind, that's an unconscious statement about the mental and emotional maturity of the Princess.

The King and the Princess meet somewhere out in the woods and walk to the castle together.  The King is noticeably distracted while the Princess talks about her day, but he brushes off her questions and changes the subject abruptly:

" My daughter"  he said, ignoring her questions, " what shall I say when one of the young men of the kingdom cometh to me to inquire about thy hand? There will be many young men at the summer contest. I would not be surprised to receive such request."

" Father, it seems that many young men seek only that which will bring pleasure or money. Some be good men, but they have not the vision for the greater tasks, nor are they willing to make the sacrifices that such tasks demand. Also, they often be proud and seek their own Glory."  She thought for a moment then continued, " it bothers me sometimes when I observe the young men in the kingdom. Do any understand the true battles of our day? Do any fight the good fight? It is this, not noble birth, that is true nobility." (pg. 241)


In real life, random commoners do not wander up to the King and ask to marry his daughter.  No.  Not going to happen.  Neither would the Princess so quickly dismiss noble birth.

Psst!  Princess!  Let me let you in on a little secret: sole bread-winners of ginormous, ever-growing families have to seek activities that bring in money all the time.  That's their main job in life besides keeping their wife pregnant yearly and being the spiritual leaders of the family.  When approached by a suitor, make sure he can bring in cold, hard cash unless you want to take a large drop in personal living standards.

The Princess derides the vision and sacrifices of the young men of the kingdom.  That's a hoot!  She lives in the lap of luxury - hell, half of the descriptions in the book read like a blurb from a linen sale catalog - but the only good she does for the community could be accomplished by an average 8 year old.  Pick up veggies for an old woman.  Play with the kids of a sick woman and orphans.  Hand fabric to a needy family.  Be a page for her father.  That's not the vision of an adult woman - so why should the readers trust her opinion of the young men of the kingdom?  I certainly don't.

Since the Princess has signaled so clearly that she'd court someone like Sir Valiant, the King continues to creep along:

Attempting to conceal his own enthusiasm, the king proceeded with another question. " My daughter, thou knowest the knight, Sir Valiant?"

The princess felt a shiver surge through her.  " Yes, thou knowest I have met him several times."

" What thinkest thou of him?" he asked calmly, rubbing his chin.

" Father, I have tried not to think of him --not because he is undesirable, but maybe because he is too desirable. I do not want to be distracted or consumed with that which is simply a dream." (pgs. 241-242)


The King has rough-rode over the Princess' thoughts, dreams and feelings through the entire book when he wasn't gaslighting her - but we are supposed to believe that he's suddenly concerned that he's unduly influencing the Princess towards Sir Valiant.  Nope, that's completely unbelievable based on everything we've seen so far in the book.

The Princess use of the word "several" should be changed to "twice in a few years plus that time I saw him announce a proclamation six years ago".   The Princess and Sir Valiant are strangers; it's way too late to try and white-wash that.

The last two paragraphs shows another insidious problem in Emo-Pure: single adults have been conditioned for years to "guard their hearts" and "keep every thought captive".  They can't instantly change that pattern of behavior even if the long-awaited suitor appears and passes inspection.

The next quote is one of the most telling in the book:


"But what thinkest thou of him?"  the king asked again.

"Of what I know he is true, he is kind-hearted, and... and he is becoming."  The princess tried to read the expression on her father's face, yet continued, " I have been impressed with everything I have seen of him. I have never talked with him at length, Father, but I have wanted to... How well do you know him?"

" Well, my fair one, your mother and I have been observing him and discussing his character. He indeed has conviction and is steadfast. He knows the battles we face and is the most zealous and faithful subject." (pg. 242)
The Princess has finally learned to parrot her father's beliefs and feelings about others back to him.

 That's the only conclusion possible for why the Princess is trying to read her father's expression while talking about the fact that she finds Sir Valiant attractive - and it's quite telling that she's mastered that immediately before she gets the reward of courtship/marriage.  Good girls who do not rock the boat by thinking, expressing unpopular opinions or having feelings get married; bad girls who do any of those things sit at home as old maids.

The main trait that the Princess knows about Sir Valiant is that he's hot.  The Princess has no way of judging Sir Valiant's "truth" or "kindness of heart" when they've met for less than two hours and have only ever exchanged small talk.   The King, on the other hand, knows that Sir Valiant says exactly what the King wants to hear.   Sir Valiant hasn't made any inroads against the Dragon or Giant that are "terrorizing" the country; I'm sure we'd have heard about that.  No, he's a good toady to the King.

Perhaps I'm being too hard on Sir Valiant.  After all, he's well on his way to moving from a random, nobody knight to heir apparent of the Kingdom.  Maybe he does have more vision than the King or the Princess.  I think Sir Valiant can see himself on the throne of the Kingdom quite clearly and gaining a conventionally beautiful, subservient, childish wife is a perk.   Most disturbingly, there's no one in the story who'd be able to see clearly enough to discern the difference between an ambitious, power-hungry usurper and a humble knight who wants to serve the Kingdom - except the Alligator who is kept on the edge of things.

After all of this, the Princess and Sir Valiant are officially courting - and I use the word officially because the King announces their courtship - or is it their engagement...Ms. Mally is very unclear about these things - at the end of the Ren-State Fair:
"Finally, he announced the news everyone was waiting to hear. Sir Valiant had won the heart of the princess! Not with talent or skill, not with words or money, not with bravery or nobility, but with a heart that was pure and a life that was true. The King was careful not to offend the other knights as he applauded the character and strength of Sir Valiant. Rather, he challenged and encourage everyone to follow the way of Truth, reminding them that God is always faithful to reward the righteous." (pg. 244)


*giggles*

 Nothing like damning by faint praise, King! Let us know how you really feel about Sir Valiant.  "He's unskilled, poor, cowardly and low-born, but hey, he's not given a hunk of his heart to anyone else, so I'm marrying him off to my daughter!"

Honestly, that's poor writing construction.  The purpose of that section is to demonstrate that Sir Valiant's most important quality is his pure heart and clean, brave living.  Stacking his skills first - "He guards the Kingdom from..... His bravery during.... His service to the Crown...." followed by "Above all of these things, his heart and life shines as an example (blah, blah, blah)".  Now, the same point is made - without making Sir Valiant sound like the town idiot.

In historical terms, this would be marked as the watershed moment that lead up to the fall of the house of the King.  The King has chosen his heir apparent to be a young, unconnected commoner who has accomplished nothing in defense of the Kingdom.  It doesn't matter how carefully the King tries not to offend the other knights; his actions speak far louder than his words - and implying that Sir Valiant is God's chosen due to his righteousness isn't going to go over well, either.

There is one last section in the book - a stilted conversation between the Princess and her husband SirValiant when they return from their honeymoon.  This is supposed to be inspiring - but I found it insipid, depressing and unnerving instead.

Monday, October 9, 2017

Before You Meet Prince Charming: Chapter 12 - Part Four

A quick recap of the previous post: God arranges marriages so girls/women should sit around and wait for some combination of men to set up a courtship for them.  If a girl/woman should happen to meet a guy outside of that, ask snoopy questions about his salvation status to kill time while her parents get involved.

This section is the second half of "Young Man Takes Initiative":
If the young man meets the qualifications, if you are interested, and if the Lord so directs through his Word and your authorities, now is an opportunity to begin building the friendship. As you proceed, it is best to first continue to get better acquainted in a group setting. I know one family that simply has a particular "interested" young man come to their home several times a week for supper and just to be with the family. The whole family is getting to know him well.


If possible, it would be nice for the two families to spend some time together as well. In fact, it would be ideal if both families could become good friends and possibly have ministry together. (pg. 230)

The conditional phrase "if you are interested" is the only discussion of consent in the entire section on how God arranges marriages.  At this point, I suspect most young women would begin a relationship with the guy.  If the steps previously stated had been followed, the man and woman don't know each other at all. Certainly not well enough to object to getting to know each other at that point. 

There's no discussion of how to bail from any of the next stages (close friendship, engagement or marriage) even though two of the three are not legally binding. This implies that when a guy and a girl agree to get to know each other they've started on an unstoppable journey that will end in marriage. That would be an excellent reason to demur from getting to know anyone of the opposite gender well in CP/QF circles.

  The rest of the sentence is absurd in the context of the steps.  If a guy doesn't meet the undefined "qualifications" set by your "authorities", the girl's not going to be allowed to get to know him better.  Expecting the Lord to direct you through his Word is a phrase that sounds elegant, but has no meaning.

There are so many potential pitfalls with getting to know a romantic partner amidst large families.

  • Some families don't get out much - so adding a new person to the mix creates some unconscious power plays and rivalries about who the new person likes the best.
  • Multiply the previous idea by 10 when combining two large families.
  • It's rough enough when the person who monopolizes the conversation is one of the kids - but when Mom or Dad wants to monopolize the conversation with the new person, no one has any recourse. 
  • Getting dumped for a stranger sucks.  Having a potential suitor fall in love with your sister - or brother - would REALLY suck especially since you have no emotional coping skills from previous ended relationships.
  • All of this cozy fraternity is based on an unspoken assumption that the two families will be united in marriage.  Now, potential couples have to weigh the effects a breakup will have on their families, too.  I'm not sure which would be worse - wanting to call off a relationship when your family loves the other family or wanting to marry someone when your family has negative feelings (unrelated to your future spouse) about his family.  Either way, the pain of the broken relationship has grown much larger than the average dating relationship.
I feel compelled to point out that the relationship is in the "Casual Friendship" stage.  In the rest of the US, casual friendship would be a safe description of people on sports teams, co-workers, or that neighbor down the street.  People can certainly follow Ms. Mally's scheme - but don't be surprised when potential suitors balk at bringing their entire immediate family to pass out tracts with their not-a-girlfriend's family.  Most people have too much self-respect to be put on display for the family of a possible romantic interest if their family passes inspection.....
Close Friendship

This next phase is an exciting part of the adventure --but one still requiring much discernment, caution, and patience. It is tempting to rush ahead at this stage, rather than taking enough time to get to know each other well in a not- too - romantic environment. As much as possible, the goal is to keep your emotions in check until you determine that this indeed is the life partner God has for you.

Allow this phase to take as much time as is necessary. It is important to get to know each other well. We accomplish this not just by being together, but by doing together. Choose specific ministry projects that the two of you can work on as a team. There are also many areas that will be important to discuss during this courtship period: your purpose in life, your future ministry goals, your doctrine , your convictions, your views of family and child rearing, and your spiritual walk. But it is still best to avoid intimate talks until there is official engagement. (pg. 230-231)


My mind is boggled.

"Close friendship" is not a synonym for "courtship"to start with.  A close friendship can span decades without expectation of moving into a different stage.  A courtship is a transitional period in determining if two people are suitable for marriage.

Keeping emotions in check while actively deciding if a person is a marriage partner borders on the pathological.  Part of marriage suitability is mutual attraction as well as affection.  Refusing to acknowledge those feelings is harmful enough - but failing to recognize the absence of those feelings brings heartache down the road.

Like in dating, relationships develop on their own timeline - but extremely short or long timelines can be a sign that something is wrong.  Short courtships may miss some disconnects between partners; long courtships can be a sign that someone is uncomfortable with commitment.

Spending scads of time working on ministry projects together during the courtship is a horrible idea.  People are seeing how they fit as life partners, not ministry buddies. Being together is an important part of determining compatibility - and not only in scant moments stolen from massed family gatherings.  Once a couple marries, they won't have a chaperone available to fill silences.

Did an editor read this section or was it written piecemeal?  In previous stages, a couple learned about their life purposes, ministry goals, and spiritual walk.  That was the thrust of the "Observe" and "Have Parents Stalk Future Boyfriend" sections - so why are we rehashing this again during courtship?  Has their beliefs changed massively? 

I guess a couple can chat about doctrine, but my marriage hasn't been challenged by the differences in belief between my church and my husband's church which I suspect are more substantial than the differences between sects of CP/QF.

If a person has previous convictions or ongoing criminal legal problems, they should disclose that to suitors. Oh, I know Ms. Mally doesn't mean that type of conviction - but she should.   Josh Duggar should have disclosed his multiple molestations to his future wife and Toby Willis should have let his wife know that he rapes kids.     A whole lot of shit is apparently being swept under rugs in CP/QF land so a woman who plans to be financially dependent on her husband while raising a very large family should be damned sure her husband isn't going to end up in a pseudo-rehab center or in prison.

The idea of laying out my future family life with a man to whom I can't say "I love you", can't hug or kiss seems completely out of whack.  By reacting to perceived imbalances in dating relationships, courtship has swung too far in the other direction.
Engagement

Engagement is the home stretch towards marriage. Many long talks have already occurred, but ahead are some of the most special times and a greater level of intimacy as you enjoy a new sense of belonging to one another. A couple needs plenty of time together to have these necessary long talks that engagement requires.

But you still do not want to put yourself in any tempting situations. There are lots of opportunities to be together while just going about normal daily activities. Continue to maintain close accountability with your parents, and purpose to avoid even the appearance of evil.

Concentrate on the spiritual and continue to wait for the physical. I respect many couples I know who have chosen to reserve their first kiss for their wedding and all physical affection for marriage. (pg. 231-232)
Wow.  That's.....wow.

I don't know what Ms. Mally thinks marriage is like - but it's not a series of long, deep heart-to-heart conversations interspersed with sex.

Communication is key in a working marriage - and yet  the couple has never talked about money, family issues, sex, or end-of-life issues.  These are difficult conversations that need to happen.

Let's talk about money for a minute.  Young adults from CP/QF families are in a different situation than many engaged Americans because they generally live at home prior to marriage.  This creates some potential sticky points for a young marriage that should be discussed:

  • Each person should find out how much money their current standard of living costs - a home, car, gasoline, utilities, internet access, food, insurance, and clothing.  Next, compare those numbers to the previous year's income of the husband.  Discuss what changes will have to occur for the new couple to make their budget work.
  • The new couple will presumably live on their own.  
    • Look up the cost of either a mortgage on a two-bedroom house or the monthly rent of a similar apartment.  Assume that the apartment will require at least two month's rent as a deposit and that a house requires a 20% down payment.  (Since rampant fertility is a design of CP/QF,  I'm going to assume that a one-bedroom or studio apartment is not workable.)  
    • Next, determine the amount of cash-on-hand needed to furnish the apartment/house with a double bed, a couch, a table, and a few kitchen chairs prior to moving in.
    • Determine the daily commute costs for the husband.
    • Revamp the budget to make these numbers fit.
  • Couples in the twenties not using birth control have a 90% chance of conceiving in the first year of marriage.  
    • Determine the cost of OB visits - one first trimester, three second trimester, 6-8 third trimester visits plus costs of delivery - under your health care plan.  
    • Determine the costs of an infant health care plan including 5-6 well-baby checkups in the first year plus two sick-baby office calls and one ER visit.  
    • Estimate the costs of diapers, wipes, and formula for one year.  (Don't skip this step if you plan to breastfeed.  Some women cannot produce enough breast milk to exclusively breastfeed and some infants cannot safely grow on breast milk due to inborn metabolic issues.)
    • Assume an additional $50-100 in maternity clothing costs and random infant supplies.  (I bought all of my maternity clothes from thrift stores like Goodwill - but you will still need new bras and underwear both before and after giving birth.)
    • Add up the total costs of the previous four lines and divide by two.   This is least amount of money that having one baby every two years will cost.  
    • Revamp the budget to make the numbers fit.
Get my drift yet?  The reason many Americans have smaller family sizes is because raising offspring is expensive.  One reason many mothers work is that raising offspring is expensive.  One reason many people receive vocational training or college educations is that raising offspring is expensive.

Don't let CP/QF obsession with avoiding sexual contact before marriage hurry a marriage that will be marked by grinding poverty instead of waiting a few years for education and career prospects to pay off.

Good news!  Ms. Mally has lost most of her steam at this point so the section on marriage is short and completely unrealistic.
Marriage

In God's amazing plan, the two become one. As women, we were created to be our husbands' helpmeets. We need to remind ourselves frequently that our purpose in getting married is not to get, but rather to give. We can be assured that, as we follow God's calling and honor his design, his plan is what will bring us ultimate fulfillment and joy. (pg. 232)

I've written answers similar to this before when I hit a question on an exam that I was completely unprepared for.   Since I wasn't sure what the right answer was, I did my best to string a few concepts together and hope that I was right.... but the most common outcome was being absolutely wrong.

Ms. Mally strung together the Biblical ideas of two people becoming one in marriage, women as helpmeets, a divine plan, and what is usually derided as a "modern feminist" obsession with fulfillment for a frantic punt that sounds like no marriage I've ever seen - and no marriage I would want to be in.

Well, the chapter continues for several more pages - but it's not worth going over.  Next, we move on to the happy ending of the allegory where the Princess and Sir Valiant have a deep heart-to-heart talk after their honeymoon.